I've held off on this article as I did not feel the time was right, but it has become too evident that 4K is the next big thing for TV's and digital video recording. Many of us are lucky enough to own camcorders or cameras that output 1080p quality video, but now that 4K is becoming increasingly popular, should we toss those devices aside and purchase a 4K camera? I would like to argue that (for now) 1080p can suffice for 4K videos, and I would like to show you how and why...
Back in the Day
Just before I was about to be a sophomore, I switched high schools. I was late to the party so I only had a few choices for my electives. I opted for a video class that I thought would be easy; boy, was I wrong!
The former teacher was known to be very lax and the video class had been easy. But the current teacher wanted his students to really learn how to create video projects at a high standard. Before you were allowed to even touch a NLE (Non-Linear Editor), you had to learn how to edit with VHS. While not as hard as editing 8mm with a film splicer, it was still an arduous task. Once you had done one project on a VHS editing bay, you could then move onto a NLE.
When I first sat down in front of a computer (loaded with Adobe Premiere), I didn't know where to start. I could open the program, but that was about it. So I pulled over a classmate and asked them one question: Which button cut the video. From then on I educated myself on all the skills and technical aspects of production and post-production.
I was fortunate enough to get into digital video just before 24p became a huge revolutionary way to capture and output video. For the younger crowd, it was much like the jump from SD to HD (1080p). For newer crowds it will be akin to 1080p to 4K. I wouldn't say that things were simpler back then, but because there was less to contend with, it did give a sturdier background for digital video and all the new features that would start to arise.
Originally I wanted to do something in computers, but since that first class in high school, I have continued my studies and experimentation in digital video. I even went on to get a degree in film and media. That's not to say I forgot about computers altogether, otherwise this blog would not exist.
1080p vs. 4K
1080p is a video resolution of 1920 x 1080. 4K is a video resolution of 4096 x 2160. There are other 4K resolutions, but I won't get into that here (check "14 Things People Get Wrong..."). 4K is roughly 4 times larger than 1080p. You can check this by multiplying the numbers above then dividing the total for 4K by the total for 1080p. In pixels, the comparison is about 8 million to 2 million. This should help you understand why 4K is such better quality than 1080p, even without having a TV that will allow you to test that theory.
1080p vs. 2K
2K is a video resolution of 2048 x 1080. Again, there are some other resolutions, but I will not be getting into them. 2K is just barely taller than 1080p. 2K is the resolution used in most cinemas (there are some cinemas that do show movies in 4K).This may help understand why the need for cameras, camcorders, and TV's to have 2K never really came to fruition.
Be Forewarned
The best way to get 4K video is to obviously have a 4K camera or camcorder. A 4K smartphone may be cool, but it is not a good way to get 4K footage (even with hacked bitrates).
The only camera I know that can be hacked to become a 4K camera is the Sony F5, but the camera alone still costs thousands upon thousands of dollars. It would be better to get something like a Panasonic GH4, especially now since there are rumors that Panasonic may discontinue the line...
But if you can't afford those options, then follow along below.
Preparation for the Transformation
There are a few things you can and should do in order to make the best quality out of 1080p video footage.
The first is a pre-production step. If you own a Canon EOS, a Panasonic GH2, a GH1, or any other camera that can be hacked for higher bitrate, you should enable those settings. You will need to spend some ample research on how these are performed, how they can react, and how to reverse the process if needed. For an applicable Canon, you can use Magic Lantern, which will give you a setting to increase the bitrate. The process is easily reversible by just pulling out your battery. On a GH1 or GH2, the process is a little more in-depth as you need to actually replace the firmware and find a respective mod that will increase your bitrate (the Driftwood Moon or Cake is a good one for GH2 users). Of course, there are going to be a lot of cameras without any sort of hack, so you can skip this step if it does not apply. (Or pick up a cheap Canon that can use CHDK; camera list available here.)
For my tests I ended up using a hacked GH2 that got me about 80-100Mb/s for my 1080p footage. It came out superb and was a perfect candidate to try for a 4K upscale.
The second step is something anyone should be able to accomplish. After creating your video, but before throwing it into a NLE, download and install the free version of GoPro Studio. You can then increase your video footage's bit-depth from 8-bit to 10-bit. I won't go into the exact steps as I use NeoScene (which was a product that became discontinued when GoPro bought Cineform). They have the same capabilities, except that the GoPro Studio is an editing suite, and NeoScene includes the ability to convert AVCHD files (great for GH2 users like me!). If you want NeoScene for AVCHD footage, you may be able to find some valid serials sold on eBay. I have a posting here with the actual downloads that GoPro's site does not make available for discontinued users.
If you're asking why do the second preparation task, because you know that bit-depth is about color; it's because that this will likely help produce a better 4K version of your 1080p footage since it will have more color information when producing a top-notch 4K video. 8-bit deals with 256 colors, while 10-bit uses 1024 colors. And when doing the upscale process below, the computer is trying to produce non-existent details from details that do exist. Giving it more to work with is better than less in these circumstances.
How to Make 1080p into 2K
The easiest way to go about this is just to enlarge your video until the height is 2048 pixels high. Sure, some quality loss will occur, but not enough to be noticeable to the naked eye. To reiterate, there isn't much of a reason to do this unless you are specifically asked to do so (i.e. a client needs his digital video in 2K).
If this isn't satisfactory, you can use similar steps that will be discussed for 4K.
How to Make 1080p into 4K
Now, you could just scale 1080p footage to the dimensions of 4K, but unlike 2K, the quality will be substandard. Because we are enlarging the footage more than 4 times its original dimensions - where 2K is a slight pulling of the height - the quality will immediately take a hit and be noticeable by enthusiasts and the general public alike.
A simple way, which I do not recommend, is first scaling the 1080p footage to 4K, then use some post filter effects. You can throw on some Gaussian blur to smooth over the banding and artifacts that will undoubtedly arise, and use a bit of sharpen to get back a bit of that grain for realism's sake. This can be useful for quick jobs, but it doesn't give it the video footage quality it deserves.
Instead, you should use Adobe After Effects CC. If you don't have it, try out a trial version. If you use up the trial, either buy it or reinstall your OS and do the trial again (a bit extreme unless you have a spare computer you don't actively use).
Not long ago Adobe introduced a new "detail-preserving upscale" feature for Adobe After Effects CC. It is an effect and is fairly easy to use. The results are quite phenomenal, even moreso when compared to just a standard upscaling of the footage.
Now that you have the required tool to perform this trick, follow these steps to transform your 1080p footage into 4K:
- Open After Effects
- Select "New Composition".
- Change the values to 4096 x 2160.
- Name the composition whatever you like.
- Click "OK."
- Import the 1080p footage into your "Project" panel. (Drag-and-drop your footage on the Project panel, or right-click the "Project" panel and go to Import > File... to browse for your footage. File > Import > File... also works.)
- A "comp" will be created along with the footage import.
- Drag-and-drop the footage into your comp timeline.
- In the "Effects & Presets" panel, type in "Detail". The "Detail-Preserving Upscale" effect should appear. (If it does not, you are not on the latest version of Adobe After Effects CC.)
- Drag-and-drop the effect onto the footage in your comp timeline and it should automatically apply to your footage, and open the "Effects" panel.
- Ensure your timeline is at the beginning of your footage by dragging the time cursor to the start of the footage.
- Click the "Scale" stopwatch provided underneath the "detail-preserving upscale" effect in the "Effects" panel.
- Use the "Scale" option to increase the size of your footage until you fill the entire frame.
- Click the "Detail" stopwatch provided underneath the "detail-preserving upscale" effect in the "Effects" panel.
- Increase the amount of the "Detail" to 100%.
- Click the "Alpha" stopwatch provided underneath the "detail-preserving upscale" effect in the "Effects" panel. (This step and 17 are optional, however, it does seem to look slightly better if done.)
- Change the value from "Bicubic" to "Detail-preserving".
- Go to Edit > Add to Render Queue
- Click it.
- The render queue window should appear in place of the comp timeline. Adjust your settings as preferred.
- Click "Render".
Note: While 4096 x 2160 is true 4K, many "4K" TV's only support up to 3840 x 2160. So, you may want to check which value you should use depending on your monitor or TV that will be used for viewing.
Note II: The stopwatch is usually not needed unless you plan on changing that selected item's actions during playback. However, I found that not clicking on it for this effect made it ignore the filter altogether when outputted from the render queue. For my tests, it seemed to work if I just did the stopwatch for scaling, but to be safe you may want to do the stopwatch for all the effect properties.
There is no perfect upscaling solution, such as that, this is not a perfect solution. But this is by far the best method I have come across, as well as the least time-consuming. There will never be a perfect solution for upscaling because your are taking something smaller and making it bigger, which will always cause banding and artifacts.
Downscaling
If you don't know much about video and are thinking you should use the above steps to downscale video, don't. It's really just a waste of time. Problems in detail and quality only happen when going from small-to-big, not big-to-small. Decreasing the size of something will retain its detail and not create any of the issues noted above. You can simply scale down the footage in any NLE and be fine.
However, if you go from big-to-small, then attempt to go back by using small-to-big, the problems above will occur. It would be smarter to keep a backup of the full size as it will be perfect in comparison to trying to match the original with the solution I have presented.
4K You, 4K Me, 4K Everybody!
I have found other software to perform upscaling, but all have mediocre results and cannot come close to the quality retention Adobe After Effects provides. I should say that the larger the gap in dimensions, the less useful any of this becomes. If I try to upscale 480p to 4K, the results should look horrible regardless of what program is used. On the flip side, If trying to upscale from 4K to 6K, this method should still be valid. Because 8K is so massively large, this technique may or may not be valid when coming from a 4K source (certainly not 1080p).
If you need to test your footage, you can always upload it to YouTube where it should give you the option to use 4K when viewing. And if you need to keep the great quality of your 4K video, but need a more manageable file size for sending or uploading, check out "VP9 + Opus = WebM...", which will also have the 4K example I made.
Another thought to remember is that your footage is not 4K, just your outputted video is. For most of us, this method will suit us fine. Others may rather purchase a 4K camera for the real deal. But that doesn't mean to trade-in your 1080p camera, as you may need a dual-setup one day, and this technique can help produce a beautiful 4K video from that second camera that only offers 1080p...
I often read things where I think, "Why did they say that? They are lying to people, and if they don't know it, then they don't know enough to be writing on it!" Sometimes it's just a common misconception, sometimes it's marketing, and sometimes it's just "tech" authors who are reading a bunch of articles all at one time in an attempt to seem like they know what they're talking about. But the worst part is that if enough people follow what has been written or said, they begin to believe the lies too. Here are some of the more obvious ones to me...
1) Macs Can't Get Viruses!
They can too! This has been floating around for a long time, and many people still believe it to be true. I have wrote about this before, but this is a biggie. The reason so many people believe this is for the simple fact that they are uncommon. The most widely used OS in the world is Windows, and if you were someone who likes to create viruses, then which OS would you choose to make viruses for? Exactly. Again, I've also said this before, but Macs used to have a phrase on their site referencing that they did not get viruses. It was subsequently taken down soon after a new virus made itself public and was Mac "friendly".
2) USB 3.0 SuperSpeed+
The actual SuperSpeed name was designated for USB 3.0, which could theoretically do 5Gbit/s. SuperSpeed+ is the name used for USB 3.1, which doubles the speed to 10Gbit/s. The two are meant to be distinct from one another, but more often than not, people confuse the terms (and reasonably so). A large amount of people think SuperSpeed means USB 3.1, while others think the name has just remained the same with a bump in speed. I doubt manufacturers, especially Chinese ones that churn out the cheap devices, are going to be well-informed on this matter; making it harder to just look at something and know if it's 5Gbit/s or 10Gbit/s throughput.
3) Macs are Better For Designing
I
am not trying to pick on Macs (and reuse past items already discussed),
but this one confuses me still to this day. I continue to meet people
who believe this and it is frustrating to say the least. Firstly, there
is a difference between technical betterment and personal preference.
Just because you prefer something, doesn't actually make it better.
Secondly,
somehow this rumor has become a non sequitur for Macs. For example, I
will be discussing something or other about Macs with someone. The other
person will say, "Macs are better for graphic design." I have learned
better not to argue, and instead pose a basic question, "How are they
better?" Usually I will get an ambiguous response, or just a reiteration
of the first statement (if I'm really lucky, they don't know). I then follow
up with, "What specifically about a Mac makes it better?" By this time
the other person normally has to give up. If they continue by stating
hardware, I continue by asking how that would make them better.
Essentially,
hardware could be the only logical thing to make a Mac better at
design. But just because it is logical does not make it true. All the
hardware in any Mac is available for PC's. Not only that, the same
hardware is less expensive for a PC, and there are usually more and
better options [at least when first introduced] hardware options available for a PC.
The only time I read anything to the contrary was that way back in the
day graphic card bandwidth was actually slightly better on Macs, but that
nowadays the reverse is true...
Adobe doesn't make Photoshop and say, "Let's give Macs the better version." They come with the same features, end of story. What I'm saying is that there is no reason to think Macs are better for design unless it is your personal preference.
4) It's Better to Keep a Computer Running (Never Shutdown)
This
is a myth that countless people just blindly believe. I'm not sure
why, as it is just ignorant. Sorry, it is. This isn't to say
there's no reason to keep your computer on for lengthy periods of time. The
most obvious are: You're working on it, you will be back in a short
time, or you have a big download in the works.
The
fact is that shutting down your computer saves you energy and the life
of your computer and its components. There is no harm in shutting down a
computer if done properly. There may be risk if constantly turning it
on or off, but that would again lend to stupidity on the user's part.
I
should also mention that the computer still draws a small amount of
power when off, so some people may think that if you're going to use
energy, why not have it on instead. This is true of anything plugged
into a power source. If you actually unplug a device, instead of just
turning it off, you will save that much more power. This is where a
surge protector (with flippable switches for each additional outlet)
comes in handy.
5) Base-2 & Base-10
You
may not know what base-2 (binary) or base-10 (decimal) is, but chances
are you have come across them more times than not. Both are methods of
calculation, and one is what hard drive and SSD manufacturers love to advertise
with. The easy way to explain this is that base-10 calculates 1MB
(Megabyte) as 1,000KB (Kilobytes). Base-2 calculates 1MB as 1,024KB. So a
3TB hard drive would be 3TB according to base-10 calculations. But once
you put that 3TB into a Windows OS (Macs have been changed to display
drives as base-10 for a few years now), it should show something closer
to 2.78TB. That's because Windows is using base-2 to calculate. (My
actual 3TB shows 2.72TB, so there must be more things at play than just
the calculation, i.e. manufacturer margin of error for storage space,
reserved space for host system, etc.)
There
are valid reasons to use base-2, but the main point is that while most
of us think in terms of base-10, computers often do not. This also means
that you are not losing any storage space when buying and using a SD
card, USB flash drive, hard drive, or SSD advertised in base-10.
6) Java vs. JavaScript
Programmers
may get upset about this with people who care little about programming
and use the terms interchangeably. While both are OOP (Object Oriented
Programming) languages, the name is merely coincidental. Java was made
by someone from Sun Microsystems, while JavaScript was made by people at
Netscape and was originally called LiveScript. A major difference
is that Java can make standalone applications, while JavaScript is
required to be inside a HTML document.
And yes, that is the correct way to spell JavaScript.
7) Brick or Bricking a Phone
This is more a pet peeve of mine, but I see and hear it all the time. A lot of people will say that they "bricked" their phone, but it still operates in some capacity or another. Or that they bricked it and brought it back to life. The problem is that what they are actually talking about is a "soft brick". Bricking, or a "hard brick", means that your phone is just like a brick. It does nothing. I have soft bricked my phone on numerous occasions, but I've never bricked my phone. So if someone is using a phone and they tell you that it was bricked at some point, it's much more likely they soft bricked it instead of opening it up and actually fixing it.
RESOLUTIONS SECTION:
8) HD vs. Full HD
HD stands for high definition and refers to 720p up to 1080p (possibly 2K, as it doesn't seem to be a part of UHD). Full HD stands for full high definition, and refers to 1080p. This is important because of some of the other terms used below.
9) 720i
1080i is a common broadcast format for HD broadcasts. 1080i is interlaced and 1080p is progressive. The latter has better quality because of how it produces the picture. There is also 720p (arguably better than 1080i as well), and there a lot of people who reference 720i. These work on the same principles except for one major difference, 720i does not exist.
You may be able to produce a 720i video through software, or have some option for it on older TV sets, but there are no source devices that should be able to create 720i natively.
10) qHD vs. QHD
This is another thing I have already mentioned in the past, but should be mentioned again as I believe many smartphones will be sporting QHD screens in the next few years. QHD means Quad High Definition. It is sometimes confused as 4K, as many think that quad hi-def would be four times 1080p. Wrong, on at least two levels (one explained later)...
QHD refers to four times 720p. And QHD is actually short for WQHD, which is Wide Quad High Definition. For those looking for an easy number to use instead, it's 1440p.
qHD means quarter High Defintion. To make things more confusing, and in contrast of what I just stated above, this is a quarter of full Hi-Def. The only problem I have is that some people are writing qHD as QHD, when it is not. But it's understandable since the two actual meanings can be quite confusing.
11) 4K vs. 1080p
This is a simple one getting confused by loads of people, even friends I know who are quite knowledgeable when it comes to technology. People assume that 4K must be four times that of 1080p. Nope. 4K is actually almost 4 times 2K, and 2K should be slightly larger than 1080p (sometimes referred to with the same height). So, if anything, it should be a bit larger than six times 1080p.
12) UHD vs. 4K
UHD is Ultra High Definition. People are using 4K and UHD interchangeably, and this too is wrong. While 4K is UHD, UHD is not just 4K. UHD also includes 6K and 8K. So 4K TV's are really just partial UHD. It's a lot like having to make the distinction between a HD (720p) and a full HD (1080p) TV. You can trust me that I have had to go through the HD situation before, making it difficult for a salesperson to understand what I was actually looking for [1080p].
13) 4K UHD TV's Are Not Real 4K!
This is not something that bothers me, but is good to know if you really want to squabble over what is what. 4K was not created by TV manufactures, it was created by the Digital Cinema Initiatives consortium. The actual dimensions are 4096x2160 (note the "4096"), and actually has a special encoding standard as well. While there are some TV's that can show content in 4096x2160, most TV's advertised as 4K only do 3840x2160. So, in reality, most "4K" TV's cannot even support a height of 4000...
The Consumers Electronics Association decided to create the term UHD in 2012, several years after 4K had already been coined. This included any content of 3840x2160 and up. Thus, this is where the 4K confusion comes about. Many times TV manufacturers will try to state their "4K" TV's as "4K UHD" TV's, which is meant to be a sly way of saying that their 4K is not the real 4K.
If you want to annoy people who have fake 4K televisions (and won't admit it), you can make the point of saying that your 1080p TV is a 2K TV since it too is almost the same dimensions.
What I find weird about this is that suddenly someone(s) decided instead of using the width as the indicator, such as 1080p (1920x1080) or 720p (1280x720), that height should now be used...
14) 2K is What Dimensions?
2K seems to have varying dimensions, so this is one instance where you can be right and wrong at the same time! In digital video 2K is 2048x1080. This is just a tad taller than 1080p video. I normally use this as my reference since I deal in digital video. However, there are plenty of others:
The "reference" resolution is 2048x1536. The full-aperture resolution (I see now being used on smartphone screens) is 2048x1556. There is also the HDTV 16:9 aspect ratio resolution, 2048x1152. And finally, 2048x872, a Cinemascope 2.35:1 aspect ratio resolution. Maybe this is why it is hard to class 2K as either part of HD or UHD...
GEEK BONUS:
Zelda, the Hero!
No, she's not. If you have ever heard of the Legend of Zelda, many people assume that Zelda is the name of the hero in the game. Actual players of the game know otherwise. Link is the name of the hero, while Zelda is the princess he must save.